On one free opt-in page with the same offer, people who clicked a banner ad signed up at about 28 times the rate of people who clicked a text mail ad. Text mail sent far more clicks, but most of those clicks were people earning credits, not readers. Tag every link, judge each source by sign-ups instead of clicks, and put most of your effort where people choose to click.
When I started putting my offers out there, I did what most people do. I found every free place I could post an ad and I posted. Safelists, text mailers, anything that said "free advertising" on the front door.
And for a while it felt like it was working. The clicks came in. The dashboards moved. I'd check my numbers in the morning and see activity. 📈
Then I looked at who actually signed up. That's when it got quiet.
I tag every link I put out there, so I can see which site each visitor came from. That's the only reason I can tell you any of this. Without it, I'd still be guessing.
I took one page with one free offer and looked at where the sign-ups came from. Two sources stood out.
Same page. Same words. Same offer. The only thing that changed was where the visitor came from. And the gap wasn't small. Banner clicks signed up at roughly 28 times the rate.
The text mail sent me far more clicks overall. Over a thousand of them. It just didn't send me people.
To be fair to the numbers: these are my own counts from one page, not a study. The sign-up totals are small, so don't hold the exact 28 too tightly. But the direction was clear, and it held up over time.
Here's what took me too long to understand. On most free text mailers, members earn credits by clicking other people's ads. That's how they pay for their own mailings.
So the click is the job. They open your ad, wait out the timer, grab their credit, and move on to the next one. Reading your page was never part of the deal.
A click and a reader are not the same thing. I was counting clicks.
That's not a knock on the people. They're doing exactly what the system asks them to do. I was just reading their clicks as interest, and they weren't.
On the banner spots I used, nobody earned anything for clicking. When someone tapped a banner, it was because the picture caught their eye and they wanted to see more. That's a real choice.
A good banner also does one thing well. One picture, one idea, one reason to tap. You can't bury your point in a banner the way you can in a long email ad. That limit actually helps.
Fewer clicks. But the clicks were people.
Put a simple tag on each one so you know which site sent which visitor. If you can't see where people come from, you can't tell what's working.
A thousand clicks with nobody staying is worse than thirty clicks with three people who stick.
Make a few clean ones in the common sizes and get them in front of real eyes. Change the picture now and then so regulars see something new.
It's fine for getting a name out there. Just don't expect it to fill your list.
One page, one message, one button. When a real person lands, don't make them work to figure out what you want.
None of this is magic. Free traffic takes time and it takes patience. Some weeks are slow no matter what you do. I've had plenty of them.
But I'd rather put my time where real people see my stuff than spend another month watching click counts go up and my list stay the same. That one change saved me a lot of wasted effort.
If you take one thing from this, make it this: count the people, not the clicks. 👥
That's what our Free Marketing Report is for. We look at where your visitors come from and where they leak out, then send you the three fixes we'd make first. Free, yours to keep, no card and no pitch.
Get your Free Marketing Report →No pressure either way. If this saves you one month of chasing empty clicks, it did its job.
Talk soon,
Orlando